Main content

Arnold A. Rogow Papers on James V. Forrestal

Notifications

Held at: Princeton University Library: Public Policy Papers [Contact Us]

This is a finding aid. It is a description of archival material held at the Princeton University Library: Public Policy Papers. Unless otherwise noted, the materials described below are physically available in their reading room, and not digitally available through the web.

Overview and metadata sections

Rogow, Arnold A.

Arnold A. Rogow (1924-2006) was a political scientist, author, and psychotherapist. His main area of research was psychological explanations for politics, especially the decision-making of leaders, notably James Forrestal and Alexander Hamilton.

Rogow taught at the University of Iowa and Stanford University before becoming a professor of political science at the City College of New York (part of CUNY) in 1966, where he remained for the rest of his career. Soon after coming to New York, Rogow studied at the New York Psychoanalytic Institute and became a practicing psychotherapist in addition to his academic responsibilities. Rogow became a leading figure in the study of the psychodymanics of political behavior and was instrumental in establishing it as a cross-field interdisciplinary concentration at CUNY. He also served as the associate editor of the Journal of Conflict Resolution from 1956 to 1963 and was a member of the original editorial committee of Comparative Politics.

Rogow was a pioneer and prolific writer in the field of psychiatry and politics, and wrote or edited over a dozen books, as well as numerous articles, during his career utilizing his psychoanalytic expertise. His major works include James Forrestal: A Study of Personality, Politics, and Policy (1963), Power, Corruption and Rectitude with Harold D. Laswell (1963), The Psychiatrists (1970), The Dying of the Light: A Searching Look at America Today (1975), Thomas Hobbes: Radical in the Service of Reaction (1986), and A Fatal Friendship: Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr (1998). His book on James Forrestal, the first Secretary of Defense and the nation's highest-ranking individual to later commit suicide, was Rogow's first major work to utilize psychology to examine a political figure. Rogow relied on both the archival record and interviews or correspondence with over fifty individuals who knew Forrestal in various capacities, including some of the psychiatrists involved in treating his illness, to identify the factors which led Forrestal to commit suicide in 1949.

Arnold Austin Rogow was born on August 10, 1924 in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. He earned his B.A. in political science from the University of Wisconsin in 1947 after interrupting his undergraduate education to serve in the Army as an infantryman during World War II. Rogow earned his Ph.D. in political science from Princeton University in 1953, where he wrote his dissertation on "The Labor Government and British Industry, 1945-1951." He married Patricia Evans and they had three children: Jennifer, Sarah, and Jeanne. Rogow died on February 14, 2006 at the age of 81.

Forrestal, James (1892-1949)

James V. Forrestal (1892-1949) was a Wall Street businessman who played an important role in U.S. military operations during and immediately after World War II. From 1940 to 1949 Forrestal served as, in order, assistant to President Roosevelt, Under Secretary of the Navy, Secretary of the Navy, and the first Secretary of Defense. He was instrumental in the buildup of the Navy during World War II and an important figure in the development of the unified National Military Establishment (NME) following the war.

Forrestal began his career on Wall Street in 1916 as a bond salesman for William A. Read and Company (later Dillon, Read and Company), a banking firm that was rising in importance at that time. Except for serving in the Navy from 1917 to 1919, Forrestal remained at William A. Read and Company until 1940. Because of his success as a bonds salesman, he was made a partner in the firm in 1923 and became the "right-hand man" of the head of the firm, Clarence Dillon. Forrestal became vice-president in 1926 and company president in 1937.

Forrestal left Wall Street in June 1940 to take a position as assistant to President Roosevelt, serving as his liaison for handling the national defense program. Soon after, in August, Roosevelt appointed Forrestal to the new post of Under Secretary of the Navy under Secretary Frank Knox. The new position was designed to handle contracts, tax and legal affairs, and to serve as liaison with other government agencies. Congress had just passed the Two-Ocean Navy Act, and it fell to Forrestal to implement the expansion of the Navy it required. Under Forrestal's leadership, the procurement and production program facilitated the rapid construction of navy ships and equipment, which reached record production levels, and the Navy grew from 158,000 to 3.6 million individuals. He also established public relations offices to promote national recognition of the Navy's role in the war and worked with War Secretary Robert Patterson to solve problems of raw material supplies through a plan designed by Ferdinand Eberstadt, a close advisor to Forrestal throughout his military career.

After the death of Frank Knox in May 1944, Forrestal was appointed Secretary of the Navy, having already established his reputation as a highly capable administrator. Favoring a business-like approach, Forrestal instituted a reduction of ceremony and utilized business methods to manage the Navy and encourage production. To this end, he visited the plants to inform workers about the progress of the war and the needs of the Navy and formed the Navy Industrial Association to bring together Navy personnel and significant civilian suppliers. To better understand the needs of the Navy, Forrestal travelled to Europe twice and three times to the Pacific and undertook a study of military logistics and strategy through extensive reading. As Secretary, he oversaw the Navy in the last year of the war and the following two years of demobilization.

After the end of World War II in 1945, Forrestal argued against demobilizing too rapidly. Instead, he advocated a program of universal military training and cautioned that the nation's military strength must be maintained to enforce a lasting peace. He was, however, initially a staunch opponent of President Truman's plan to unify the Army and the Navy into a single department of national defense. Forrestal argued that the department would be too large for its head to have any meaningful understanding of it, forcing him to rely too heavily on his military advisors. He was also concerned that unification would shift the primary method of defense from naval aircraft carriers to air force bombers with atomic weapons which he felt would weaken American's military position. When President Truman continued to support unification, Forrestal enlisted Ferdinand Eberstadt to develop a compromise plan. Eberstadt's plan, which formed the basis for the National Security Act of 1947, established a single military department called the National Military Establishment (NME). The NME, led by the Secretary of Defense, combined the departments of War and the Navy and established the Department of the Air Force. However, the plan retained some of the original structure of the U.S. military by making the heads of each department somewhat independent, coordinated by the Secretary of Defense but not directly subordinate to him. The Act also established the National Security Council, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and the Central Intelligence Agency.

In September 1947, Forrestal was appointed the first Secretary of Defense. In this position, he was responsible for coordinating the activities of the U.S. military and developing national defense policy. As the first secretary, it was Forrestal's formidable task to enact the unification of the departments required by the National Security Act, coordinating the activities of the previously-independent Army (War) and Navy and overseeing the formation of the new Department of the Air Force. One of his chief obstacles proved to be the structure of the NME itself, which provided the Secretary of Defense with too little authority over the heads of the military departments. Another significant challenge was obtaining a sufficient budget for the department at a time when President Truman demanded a reduction in military spending. The limited funds exacerbated the competition between the military branches over resources. The challenges were further increased by the escalating tensions of the Cold War during Forrestal's tenure.

Despite the difficulties, Forrestal identified several important accomplishments in his first report as Secretary of Defense in December 1948, among them the development of short- and long-range strategic plans, an integrated NME budget, the definition of roles within the NME, the coordination of service procurement efforts, and the establishment of overseas unified commands. He also identified several factors that would facilitate further progress, including the significant strengthening of the Secretary of Defense's authority as well as changes to other structural elements of the NME. Many of his recommendations were part of the 1949 amendments to the National Security Act voted into law in August 1949, although by that time Forrestal had already left his post. Forrestal resigned as Secretary of Defense on March 28, 1949 and was succeeded by Louis Johnson, previously Assistant Secretary of War.

James Vincent Forrestal was born on February 15, 1892 in Beacon, New York to James and Mary A. (Toohey) Forrestal. He began his college education at Dartmouth College in 1911 and transferred to Princeton University the next year as a member of the Class of 1915. At Princeton, Forrestal was chairman of The Daily Princetonian, a member of the student council, and voted "most likely to succeed" by his class. After Princeton, Forrestal briefly held positions at the New York World, the New Jersey Zinc Company, and the Tobacco Products Corporation before beginning his career on Wall Street. Forrestal married Josephine Ogden, a columnist for Vogue magazine, in October 1926. They had two sons, Michael and Peter. Forrestal committed suicide on May 23, 1949 at the National Naval Medical Center in Bethesda, Maryland while being treated for depression and occupational fatigue similar to that suffered by service men in battle. Upon being informed of his death, President Truman said "This able and devoted public servant was as truly a casualty of the war as if he had died on the firing line."

The Rogow Papers are composed of materials he collected for his book James Forrestal: A Study of Personality, Politics, and Policy (The Macmillan Press: New York, 1963) and include correspondence with individuals who knew Forrestal, Rogow's notes, and other research materials. Also included are copies of some of Forrestal's correspondence and materials related to the publication of the book.

The following sources were consulted during the preparation of the biographical note: "Arnold A. Rogow, 81, a Writer Who Put History on the Couch" by Douglas Martin. The New York Times, March 2, 2006. Daily Closeup: "A Sickness..." by Lindsy Van Gelder. The New York Post, April 10, 1970. Obituary of Arnold A. Rogow by Benjamin Rivin. Comparative Politics, v. 39, no. 1, October 2006.

Gift of Arnold A. Rogow in November 2001 [ML.2001.009].

For preservation reasons, original analog and digital media may not be read or played back in the reading room. Users may visually inspect physical media but may not remove it from its enclosure. All analog audiovisual media must be digitized to preservation-quality standards prior to use. Audiovisual digitization requests are processed by an approved third-party vendor. Please note, the transfer time required can be as little as several weeks to as long as several months and there may be financial costs associated with the process. Requests should be directed through the Ask Us Form.

This collection was processed by Adriane Hanson in 2009. During processing in 2009, materials were arranged into series and re-housed. Finding aid written by Adriane Hanson in April 2009.

No information is available about whether material was separated during accessioning in 2001 or processing in 2009.

Publisher
Public Policy Papers
Finding Aid Author
Adriane Hanson
Finding Aid Date
2009
Sponsor
These papers were processed with the generous support of the National Historical Publications and Records Commission (NHPRC).
Access Restrictions

Collection is open for research use.

Use Restrictions

Single copies may be made for research purposes. To cite or publish quotations that fall within Fair Use, as defined under U. S. Copyright Law, no permission is required. For instances beyond Fair Use, it is the responsibility of the researcher to determine whether any permissions related to copyright, privacy, publicity, or any other rights are necessary for their intended use of the Library's materials, and to obtain all required permissions from any existing rights holders, if they have not already done so. Princeton University Library's Special Collections does not charge any permission or use fees for the publication of images of materials from our collections, nor does it require researchers to obtain its permission for said use. The department does request that its collections be properly cited and images credited. More detailed information can be found on the Copyright, Credit and Citations Guidelines page on our website. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact us through the Ask Us! form.

Collection Inventory

Scope and Contents

The Chapter Files series contains materials Rogow collected to write chapters 2-9 of his book James Forrestal: A Study of Personality, Politics, and Policy (The Macmillan Press: New York, 1963). The majority of the material is copies of or excerpts from articles in The New York Times and other newspapers, portions of Forrestal's published diaries, and articles and speeches written during and after Forrestal's career in the U.S. military during World War II. Also included are Rogow's notes on his research and interviews he conducted and partial drafts of a few of the chapters.

Arrangement

Arranged in numerical order by chapter number.

Physical Description

1 box

Chapter 2: A Career in the Making, 1933-1962. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Chapter 3: Introduction to Politics and Chapter 4: Complacency, Communism, and the Cold War, 1943-1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Chapter 4: Complacency, Communism, and the Cold War, 1939-1945. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Chapter 5: National Security and Power Politics, 1944-1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Chapter 6: Soviet Expansionism and Defense Organization, 1946-1962. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Chapter 7: "Victim of the Washington Scene", 1945-1947. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Chapter 8: Secretary of Defense, 1948-1949. 2 folders.
Physical Description

2 folders

Chapter 9: James Forrestal: An Appraisal and a Memorial, 1943-1962. 2 folders.
Physical Description

2 folders

Scope and Contents

The Correspondence series is composed of Rogow's correspondence with individuals that Rogow wanted to interview for his book James Forrestal: A Study of Personality, Politics, and Policy (The Macmillan Press: New York, 1963). The correspondents included military officials, civilians Forrestal worked with in government and in business, Congressmen, doctors involved with his medical treatment, and Princeton University classmates. Rogow wrote each individual requesting interviews or information and access to any documents they had pertaining to Forrestal. Their responses typically included their impressions of Forrestal, suggestions of other people Rogow should contact, and acceptance or declination of his request for an interview.

Arrangement

Arranged alphabetically by correspondent.

Physical Description

2 boxes

Abbott, Vera W, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Acheson, Dean, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Antrim, Archie, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Baldwin, Hanson, 1958-1962. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Barringer, Philip E, 1960. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Baruch, Bernard, 1959-1960. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Blough, Glennoirre, 1960-1961. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Branca, Aileen, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Briggs, Maria, 1959-1960. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Campbell, C. Lawton, 1960. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Chesney, Earle, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Clifford, Clark, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Cox, William J, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Davis, Vincent, 1963. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Deutsch, Albert, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Dewey, Thomas, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Dilworth, Richardson, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Dix, William (Princeton Library), 1958. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Dodson, Frederick, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Donovan, William, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Douglas, William O, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Draper, William, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Dunnington, Walter, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Eberstadt, Ferdinand, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Engle, Clair, 1960. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Forrestal, Henry, 1959-1960. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Foster, E. D, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Gilmore, P, 1960. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Gingrich, John E, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Greene, Jerry, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Grove, Brandon, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Henry, Robert L, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Hensel, H. Struve, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Hillman, William (Broadcast on Forrestal's Death), 1949. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Hoyt, Austin, 1960. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Johnson, Lewis, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Kellett, Roderick, 1960. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

L'Etang, Hugh, 1959-1963. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Lovett, Robert, 1959-1960. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Mahon, George, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Matthews, Howard, 1960. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Noble, John, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Pearson, Drew, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Putnam, Alfred, 1960. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Raines, George N, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Rayburn, Sam, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Ridder, Joseph, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Rodgers, W. S. S, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Royar, Murrey, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Schaffer, Leslie, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Scott, Edgar, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Strauss, Lewis L, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Taylor, E. B, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Vinson, Carl, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Warner, Caleb, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Willcox, Westmore, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Young, William B, 1959. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Miscellaneous, 1963. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Scope and Contents

The Related Materials series includes materials pertaining to Rogow's research for his book James Forrestal: A Study of Personality, Politics, and Policy (The Macmillan Press: New York, 1963) and to the book's publication. Research materials include excerpts from speeches and articles by and about Forrestal, newspaper clippings about Forrestal and the medical treatment and privacy rights of public figures, the Federal Bureau of Investigation's (F.B.I.) file on Forrestal, Rogow's notes on his research, and notes and interview questions written by journalist John McLain in preparation for a biography he intended to write on Forrestal. Materials on the book's publication include correspondence to obtain permission to publish quotes and regarding the possibility of publishing a paperback edition of the book, and readers' responses to the book.

Arrangement

Arranged alphabetically by type (e.g. correspondence) or subject, with miscellaneous files at the end of the series.

Physical Description

2 boxes

Correspondence Regarding the Book, 1963-1965. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Leslie, Frank, 1959-1964. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

McLain Notes, 1940-1962. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Newspaper Articles, 1941-1948. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Notes for Revisions, 1940-1951. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Paperbacks, 1982. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Permissions, 1962-1964. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Political Philosophy, 1945-1947. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Relations with Truman, 1945-1962. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Used (Material from The New York Times ), 1940-1941. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Miscellaneous, 1947-1963. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Miscellaneous, 1949. 1 folder.
Physical Description

1 folder

Miscellaneous, 1989-1993. 1 folder.
Scope and Contents

(Includes a copy of the F.B.I.'s file on Forrestal.)

Physical Description

1 folder

Print, Suggest